Caveat Scriptor

No author ever thinks they will be the next victim in a scam. But every year, hundreds of authors fall prey to unsavory publishing houses that bilk them out of their creative work and their money.

Here’s a list of characteristics from Writers Beware that tell you that you’re looking at a scam publisher:
1. Fee-charging–whether for the actual printing/production of the book, or for some other item related to the publishing process, such as editing or publicity. Some publishers require authors to buy bulk quantities of their own books. Fees range from a few hundred dollars to more than $25,000. A nominal “advance” in the face of other fee-charging practices does nothing to legitimize them.

2. Author-unfriendly contracts–including rights grabs, taking copyright, restrictive option clauses, sub-standard royalty provisions (including reverse-accounted royalties), inadequate reversion clauses, draconian “defamation clauses,” and a host of other inappropriate and abusive contract terms.

3. Deliberately misleading advertising–including directly soliciting authors, misrepresenting services to authors in an effort to masquerade as commercial publishers, hiding the fact that they are vanity operations, and making false claims about distribution and bookstore presence.

4. Conflicts of interest–some publishers are the vanity “arm” of (or otherwise under common control with) a fee-charging literary agency, which directs clients to the publisher under the guise of having made a “sale”–often without revealing the financial and personnel links between the two businesses.

5. Lack of editorial gatekeeping–as befits vanity operations, many of these publishers have few, if any, standards for the books they acquire. Some don’t even bother to read the books they accept for publication.

6. Poor or inadequate editing. Some of these publishers don’t even pretend to provide editing. Others do little more than run the text through a spell and grammar checking program, or employ unqualified, inexperienced staff.

7. Repeated breach of contractual obligations–such as nonpayment of royalties, refusal to provide royalty statements, incorrect accounting, publication delays, ARCs not sent for review as promised, failure to ship books or fulfill orders, failure to make author changes in proofs, and failure to respond properly to author queries and communications. Some of these publishers have been the focus of successful litigation and other legal actions by authors.

Any of that look familiar?

If a publisher you’re dealing with displays any of these characteristics, get away from them as fast as you can. They are not legitimate publishers.

The following sites offer warnings about questionable publishers. If a publisher that you’re dealing with, or considering dealing with, appears on any of them, run the other way.

Absolute write
Editors and Predators
Writer Beware

For example, Mystic Press and Phoenix Fire publishing appear on all three.


4 thoughts on “Caveat Scriptor

  1. I’m a little surprised that Dave’s warning on P&E didn’t mention that PF is a vanity publisher, along with his “not recommended” statement. He’s mentioned the vanity press status of quite a few others on his list.

    • There are a few elements about PF as it exists now (illegally) that might be different from the last time he looked. Like those imprints and “freelance” services.

  2. If you’re an author that had a book published on Createspace through Mystic Press, Tabetha Jones or Phoenix Fire publishing and you want information about how many sales your book has had, you can contact Createspace at 1-866-356-2153 to find out for yourself. Or contact them at Outside the US or Canada, call 001-206-508-4011. They’ll be happy to help you. Gone are the days when information had to go through her so she could tell you whatever she wanted.
    Current victims: find out for yourself if you’re getting everything you deserve.
    Past victims: find out how much she scammed you for so you can tell the world, with proof in black and white.
    Have at thee.

  3. Update:

    As of June, 2016, Tabetha Jones has no publishing companies in operation that we know about, so our investigation of her has been halted. The point of examining her in the first place was to advocate for authors that reported no royalties and other related abuse from her. If she’s not involved with publishing anymore, that job’s done.

    The posts about her remain in public view in case she starts a new one in the future.

    If more publishing concerns about Tabetha Jones (Willis, Farmer Hoover, Saulters, etc) – AKA Zooey Sweete, Emerald Rai Fleurs, et al – arise in the future, we will post relevant updates. But for now, we’re focusing on happier topics.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s